Wednesday, May 5, 2010

Period 4

Read the above post and respond here.

25 comments:

Anonymous said...

4.14
toss customs
The plan that the friar had for getting Romeo and Juliet was a good idea but was very risky. the potential hazards were death and a war. the benefits of the plan were the ending hate between the families. It would have worked if the friar's letter was delivered on time or if juliet woke up just before Romeo came. some of the alternatives to the plan were just Juliet run away with Romeo. i don't think that friar should be blamed for what happens.

Anonymous said...

4.25 upside-down smily face

His plan is bad, The mail could be slow or get lost so she could get trapped in the crypt and juliet should have run away at night if romeo was able to go in and out of her room with no problems why couldn't she just go and ran away with Romeo. I also feel that they should not have gone through with the friers plan at all it is not as planed out as they hoped. All in all, his plan was bad.

Anonymous said...

4.1
The friar's plan for getting Romeo and Juliet together is not a good idea. His plan has a lot of faults. Juliet could stifle in her family tomb or Romeo could not get the friar's letter on time. The plan is faulty but if it actually works then Romeo and Juliet could be together. I don't think the plan could of worked because it was fate. An alternative to their plan could of been leaving during the night to Mantua. I would go along with the plan if I was in their situation because its less dangerous than taking the potion. The friar should not be blamed for what eventually happens sense Juliet agreed to it.

Anonymous said...

4.4.futo kan
I think that the Friar's plan isn't very good. I think that the Friar should have simply had Juliet disappear. Once Juliet was thought to be dead and gone and Romeo came back they would announce their marriage. I also think that the Friar should be blamed for the failure of the plan because there was to many ways for the plan to be messed up. All in all I prefer my plan rather then the Friars.

Anonymous said...

4.13 Britt

The friar has a good idea but there are a few things that are very risky. The plan could end in Juliet dying in the crypt because of suffocation and Romeo could have gotten caught when he was going to rescue Juliet. The friar's idea could have worked if they put a little more thought into the plan. I think that Juliet should have ran away to where Romeo was and her parents would just have to deal with the fact that she is gone. I would have considered the plan but I would have also tried to make another plan.I think the friar is somewhat responsible for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet.

Anonymous said...

4.1
I agree with our alternative plan 4.14.

Anonymous said...

4.4.futo kan
I agree with 4.1 because we have the same ideals.

Anonymous said...

4.25 wow cows
I agree with futo kan that it was not a good plan and it was not planed out good.

Anonymous said...

4.4.futo kan
I dissagree with 4.14 because the Friars plan was bad.

Anonymous said...

4.25 WHAT NO

i agree that he the frier had good intentions but it was not thought out

Anonymous said...

4.16
The friar's plan to get Romeo and Juliet together isn't a great idea. The potential hazard is that something could go wrong and Juliet dies. The benefits of the plan is at the end Romeo and Juliet will be together. It could not work because the plan doesn't sound good. I would not go with the plan. Why I wouldn't go with it because the plan sounds stupid. The friar shouldn't be blamed because its not his fault.

Anonymous said...

4.2 bossman666
Is the friar's plan a good idea? I think at the time and situation it is.I mean in Juliet's situation she says it is the only way. So she is gonna have to pick something and quick.Plus I also think they should have told romeo before Juliet took the potion. All an all,I think iot's a pretty good plan.

Anonymous said...

4.1
Both the friar and Juliet should be blamed for the failure of the plan sense she went along with it 4.4.

Anonymous said...

4.1
Both the friar and Juliet should be blamed if the plan fails sense she went along with it 4.4.

Anonymous said...

4.09. Ashlee Taylor<3


The friar's plan for getting Romeo and Juliet together is a good idea because they are married and want to be together. It would be the dumbest idea ever if friar married Romeo and Juliet and now marry Paris and Juliet. The hazards or drawbacks are Juliet has to fake a a death; in which she could actually die, go crazy. The alternatives are tell Juliet's parents she is married to Romeo or run away. The friar should be blamed for what eventually happens because its his fault.

Anonymous said...

4.16
I agree with 25 because the friar's plan isn't a good idea.

Anonymous said...

4.13 Britt

I agree with 4.1 because they have a good point. 4.25 because they also make a good point

Anonymous said...

4.16
I agree with 1 since the plan has many mistakes.

Anonymous said...

4.2 bossman666
I disagree with 4.4 because Juliet doesn't have a choice.

Anonymous said...

4.5 Big Red
I think that the friar's plan is kinda smart. I think that there is a high risk for problems. I think that if this works they could end up together. I think that there was a possibility that they could have worked because the plan had a chance to work. I think that Juliet could have thought a little bit longer and found a different outcome. They could have ran away together. I don't think that I would go through with that plan.I don't think that the plan had a high chance to go right. I don't think that the friar can be held fully responsible.

Anonymous said...

4.7

I think that the friar's plan is bad. it's a bad plan because something can go wrong. well some potential drawbacks are that juliet can wake up too early and panic or romeo might not get the note to go save juliet. some potential benefits are that romeo and juliet might get away with it. the plan could have worked if they would have waited. I actually would go along with it because juliet's parents are too unfair. The friar should get blamed for what happens because he was the one that had the idea. All in All, I think that their plan could have worked if they would have been patient.

Anonymous said...

4.7

I agree with 4.14 because the friar's plan was kind of risky.

MuDvAyNe said...

4.27
I do not think that the plan is a good idea. I don't think this because one problem could be that she could wake up to early and panic or suffocate. Another problem is that she could not wake up at all if the medicine doesn't work. Maybe one of the up side to it could be that if it all works both of them could be together for the rest of their life's. I do think that it could work if they had it all planed out better and waited a longer time for romeo to get the letter for sure. I defiantly would not go through with the plan because I do not want to die en my own families crypt. I think that the firer should be to blamed because he was the one that put all of the project together.

Anonymous said...

4.7

I also agree with 4.5 because the plan is good but in a way dangerous.

hot shot said...

I think the friars' plan is a very Smart plan because faking a death is a very smart thing to do. The reason for this suggestion would be for a serious matter as of Romeo and Juliet problem. If the friar helped everyone with there problems he would be famous for what he does.