Wednesday, May 5, 2010

Period 2/3

Read the above post and respond here.

17 comments:

Anonymous said...

19
2-3

Friar Lorence's idea for getting Romeo and Juliet together is a terrible idea. If Juliet is berried under ground, there is a high risk of suffocation leading to death. There is only one benefit to the plan, and that is if the plan works, they are together forever. It could work, because it's actually looks like she's dead, then when she awakens, Romeo is there. I would have gone along with the plan, because the violence needs to stop. The Friar shouldn't be blamed for what eventually, because he is a Holy man trying to stop terror. In conclusion, the Friars' plan is a bad idea with many down falls.

Anonymous said...

2/3 #3
The Friar's plan to get Romeo and Juliet together is a good idea because once they meet they can leave the city together or tell the family about their marrage. The potential drawbacks of the plan is Romeo gets their late. The benefit of this plan is that the two lovers can see each other agian. It could have worked but not as well as the Friar might have thought. An alternative plan would be to sneek Juliet out of the city. I would have not gone with the plan if I were in either position, this is because something might go wrong with the plan. I think that the Friar should not be blamed because he was only helping the two lovers and believed that if both families were one the fighting would stop.

Anonymous said...

Well he thinks it will stop the dislikes that the family`s have for each other so it could be.That they could get them self`s killed.That they could bring peace between there family`s.It could of but did not because they killed there self`s.Just not of talked to each other.I don`t think so i would of left most likely.um he should not because juliet came to him for help.

Anonymous said...

Computer #26 Period 2/3

The Friar's plan is a good plan because Romeo ad Juliet love each other and they are married. Another lesson I learned that is part of the ten commandments is do not cheat on your spouse or partner. Juliet should be able to make her own choices even though she's still thirteen and she's a big girl. She's turning fourteen and she should have the god given right to choose who she loves and who she marries. I personally think that Juliet and Romeo should be married because we all know that Juliet's a Capulet and Romeo's a Montague and we should probably marry someone from a different family and not in the same family. I think it's wrong to marry someone from the same family. It's better to marry someone from a different family. The Friar's plan is good because he vows to marry Romeo and Juliet but changes his mind and decided to marry Paris and Juliet because Romeo is banished by the prince. It's unfair to love someone and be banished so you cannot see them for a long time.

Anonymous said...

2/3.14
I don't think the friar's plan is a good idea, because it's dangerous and people can get hurt. The potential hazards are that juliet could die from being around her dead family she could also suffocate i the coffin if she wakes up. Romeo could think she is really dead and since his love is dead he could ill him self because the message didn't get to him about the plan. I would not go with the plan if i was juliet because i would not want to wait in a coffin sourounded by dead people, i also wouldn't want to worrie if i was gonna die from potion that the friar gives me. I think that the friar should be blamed for what happens because he's the one that made this great amazing plan to get them together and he's also the one that gives juliet the potion to make it look like she is dead and the friar is also the one that is supposed to send romeo the message to meet juliet and wake her up, so if anything bad happens its really all the friars fault its nobody else's. Over all i think that the whole plan of juliet pretending to be dead and everything should not happen its to risky.

Anonymous said...

#1 2/3

I think the Friar's plan for getting Romeo and Juliet isn't a good idea because their are two different hateful families against each other. The two families would hate each other more if they got with each other. Two hateful families, Romeo and Juliet together, deaths alright, it would work out because it would bring peace. I don't know what could have been some alternatives to the plan. I probably would gone along with the plan so Juliet don't marry Paris and could be with Romeo. The friar shouldn't be blamed for anything he didn't know the wedding was a day earlier and things also gone wrong. But I think they should get together so the two families should be peaceful to one another

Anonymous said...

I agree with computer #3 because once they do meet and fall madly in love they can elope and be married. Romeo and Juliet should tell their parents because not only it's the right thing to do they are not hiding it from their parents much longer and it's their choice who they marry not their guardians choices. Capulet should let Juliet choose a husband for herself and Capulet should deal with it if he has an issue with Juliet's choice.

Anonymous said...

Computer #26 period:2/3

I personally agree with computer #1 because if the families hate each others guts why make the issue worse by hooking Romeo and Juliet up. It will make it worse even if the Capulets and Montagues are in warfare with each other. But I still like my opinion in my opinion.

Anonymous said...

computer:eiqht period:two(=

I agree with computer one, because if they didn't died at the end the family would have to bring peace to make their children's happy.

Anonymous said...

15.2/3
#3 i agree the friar should put them together

Anonymous said...

Computer #26 Period:2/3

Friar's plan is a so-so plan. I changed my mind. What's good about his plan is that he wants to marry Romeo and Juliet behind Capulet's back so he won't know Juliet married Romeo. What's bad about it is I think that Juliet lied to her father and Romeo sneaks out to see Juliet. That's what gets the Capulet and Montague families angry and more warfare with each other.

Anonymous said...

period 2/3
computer 17*

Yes I think the Friar's plan for Romeo && Juliet to qet back toqether is a good plan. The rewards for Romeo && Juliet are for them to be toqether. I think it could of worked if it was planned better. If it were me I would definitely do that.

Anonymous said...

15.2/3
i disagree with u i guess if they want to be together and that`s what it takes they should be able to do it

Anonymous said...

#23
2/3

Yes Friar's plan is a good one because they both are in love. Well some draw backs are the two diffrent families thaty don't like each other. But some of the rewards is that romeo and juliet will be together like they wanted. Yes it could work if they could make it work. An alternative to the plan is that juliet fakes her death so her and romeo kan be together. I don't no what i would do if i was in there position. Maybe because he helps juliet fake her own death.

Anonymous said...

i think it was a good idea but they need to get their stories stright. the hazards of the plan was the letter getting to romeo in time. some benefites of the plan are they
2/3#27

will get to see ether. i think no because juliet get married to paris to early. calling romeo and telling him could have been an altrernitive.i would have not gone along with the plan because its to risky.all in all then plan would not have worked.

Anonymous said...

Computer #26 Period:2/3

I think it's unfair because it should be the kid's choices to marry who they want to marry.I'm going through the same situation right now.

Anonymous said...

computer:eiqht, period:two<3
.::cupcake[=

I disagree with cupcake, beacuse the plan wasn't a good idea.