Personally, the friar's plan is absolute crap. It is about the equivalent of shooting a man out of a cannon, to get him to the moon. By inducing a catatonic state within Juliet, he automatically assumes Romeo will be there on time. But now, one thing changed, and is jeopardizing the entire plan! Such a poorly structured plan was expected to fail. Juliet simply could have run away with Romeo when he first left! In conclusion, the plan sucks, and the friar should have thought of something a lot easier to accomplish rather than a quick fix right on the dot.
In my opinion, the Friars plan of getting Romeo and Juliet together was bad. One bad thing about his plan is that when he gives Juliet the potion,he doesn't know that it wont kill her. The good part about the plan was that it would bring Romeo and Juliet together. The plan would work if Lord Capulet hadn't moved the wadding to Wednesday because by that time Romeo would have gotten the message. If could change the plan I would have just told them to just run away and never come back. If I were in Juliet's position I would have gone along with the plan if there was nothing else. In conclusion, the Friar should not be blamed for what eventually happens because if its anyones fault,its Lord Capulets.
The friars plan for getting romeo and juliet together isn't good. The friars plan is bound to have something wrong. The plan could of worked if it was planned better. An alternative to the plan is juliet just running away. I wouldn't of went with the plan. The friar could be blamed for the killings. In conclusion the plan wasn't that good
1.8 I think that the Friar was right to get Romeo and Juliet together because they loved each other. The benefits of Romeo and Juliet being together would be that it could bring the families to get along. I think it could of worked if Romeo and Juliet would of talk to their parents and confessed to them what they did. I think that instead of Juliet drinking the potion she should of ran away with Romeo and then came back with him like a day after the wedding day. I wouldn't go with the plan because i wouldn't drink any kind of potion. I would just run away with Romeo. I think it was the Friars fault in the way that he married them, but then again it wasn't his fault because Romeo and Juliet are the ones who decided to get married.
1. -The Friar's plan for getting Romeo and Juliet together wasn't a good idea from the start. For one thing Juliet didn't know if the potion would work or if the after affects would effect her in a bad way. Another way Romeo and Juliet would of been able to be together. Would be to sneak out at night and run away. All in all the Friar should be blamed for what happened because it was his herb.
1.12 Yes I think it is a good idea but in not sure if its going to work. It could be a poison or it won't work. Romeo and Juliet can be together in happiness. Im not sure it would ever work because I don't think they could make a potion. Have her run away and Romeo meet her somewhere. Yes I would go along with it because it would be fun. I don't know what happens so I can't tell you. In conclusion, I like what the friar is trying to do.
The Friars plan to get Romeo and Juliet together is a very good idea. The drawbacks are the chances of Romeo does not come, Juliet dies, or the potion does not work. The benefits are Romeo and Juliet are set free to love each other. An alternative plan could have been Juliet could have just ran away. I would not go through with the plan. All and all, the Friar is not to blame because they killed them selfs.
period 1. Computer 20. In my opinion the Friar's plan is not a very good idea because there is very many good and bad consequence to it. The potential benefits/rewards of it is that Romeo and Juliet might end up being able to be together, but Juliet could also die,the potion could be poison, and Romeo might not save Juliet in time. It could have worked if the Friar got the information to Romeo on time to tell him before he killed hims self. They could have told Romeo before Juliet took the potion and Romeo would have known before he killed himself. If I was Juliet i would not have gone along with the plan because of the consequences that could happen. In conclusion, the Friar should be blamed for what eventually happens to Romeo and Juliet.
Period 1. #19. I think that the Friar's plan for getting Romeo and Juliet together is a good idea for their time period. The potential drawbacks/hazards of the plan are if Romeo doesn't get the message then something bad can happen,they will have to leave their families, and the potion might not work. The potential benefits/rewards of the plan are they will be together, and their families might stop fighting.I think that the plan could have worked if Romeo gets the message in time. Some alternatives to the plan could be the Friar could go and tell Romeo face to face instead of a letter. If I was in Romeo's or Juliet's situation I think I would have gone along with the plan because it seems like a pretty good idea. All in all, I think that the Friar should be blamed but not just him because all he did was secretly marry them and was trying to help them so it is partly his fault.
#24 The friars plan may not seem like a good idea, but its the only one that he can think of. The potential drawback is that what if romeo may never get the message. The benefits are that if the plan works then they will be together. I'm not sure what a different plan would have been. If I was in Romeos posistion i think i would do anything to be with her. The friar should not be blamed for what happens. It is not his fault.
#23/per1 The plan the Friar had was overly complicated. There for it was a terrible plan. A better plan would have been just have Juliet run away with Romeo. that would have worked perfectly, they couldn't have been tracked. The friar probably knew it would end in death. How the hell does his plan end well she ether suffocates or goes insane or lives it all ends in DEATH! Yay death. So clearly the Friar is an idiot and his plan was terrible. If it where me i would tell him think of something else.
1.09 I think that the Friar's plan is not very good. The hazards are that Juliet can suffocate, or the friar can give her poision instead of a potion. I can't think of any benefits. I don't think the plan could have ever worked, but im not sure why I just dont. I probably wouldn't of gone along with it, because there is some hazards. an alternative would be to run away. The friar should be part of the blame for being the person to come up with the plan, but also Romeo and Juliet's fault for going along with it.
The friar's plan to get Romeo and Juliet together was a good idea and for good reasons. The potential drawbacks/hazards of the plan are that the family's could find out early and kill the friar and Romeo and Juliet could be separated forever which would lead them to commit suicide. The potential benefits/rewards of the plan could be that they family's could see the love because of these two loves which could make them stop the fighting. The plan could have worked because Romeo and Juliet are very secretive about meeting each other. Some alternatives to the plan could have been to go to a different city and get married and live long lives together. I would have gone along with the plan in Romeo and Juliet because it would be in the name of love peace and happiness. In conclusion, the friar shouldn't be blamed for what eventually happens because the messenger fault for being to slow and Juliet's fault for telling her father that she is willing to marry Paris.
period 1. computer 20 I completely agree with number 25 but i want to know how it would be lord Capulet's fault? He made his point clear when he said if any "drama" was created in Verona that they would be banished and he let Romeo go easy when he only banished him instead of killing him.
#23 to any one who reads this. Where did he learn that kind of potion only medicine men who studied santaria knew that so something seems off to me....
1.11: The friar's plan for getting Romeo and Juliet together is not a good plan. THe potential hazards of this plan is if the potion doesn't work and Juliet actually dies, or if it doesn't work and she has to marry Paris. In which case she threatened to kill herself. The potential rewards of the potion plan is to get Romeo and Juliet together. I do not think the plan could have ever worked because Romeo is rash. Even if the friar himself warned Romeo he would probably act the same. One alternative to the plan could have been to get Juliet banished, too, or even help her run away. I don't think I would go along with the plan because I would be scared that the potion would really kill me. All in all the friar should be blamed for what eventually happens because it was his plan, and he married them in the first place.
The Friar's plan for Juliet is to give her the potion and make her look dead. So the parents think she is dead. It is not a good idea because Juliet will never get to see her parents again. The drawbacks of the plan would be for the potion to not work and her to kill herself. The benefit of the plan would be that she can marry who she wants because the parents think she is dead. It could have worked but i would never want to do that because i want to see my parents. I would not go along with the plan because i love my parents and i would not want to be separated from them. Yes the Friar should be blamed for what happens.
26 comments:
P1.#25
Personally, the friar's plan is absolute crap. It is about the equivalent of shooting a man out of a cannon, to get him to the moon. By inducing a catatonic state within Juliet, he automatically assumes Romeo will be there on time. But now, one thing changed, and is jeopardizing the entire plan! Such a poorly structured plan was expected to fail. Juliet simply could have run away with Romeo when he first left! In conclusion, the plan sucks, and the friar should have thought of something a lot easier to accomplish rather than a quick fix right on the dot.
Period 1 computer 5
In my opinion, the Friars plan of getting Romeo and Juliet together was bad. One bad thing about his plan is that when he gives Juliet the potion,he doesn't know that it wont kill her. The good part about the plan was that it would bring Romeo and Juliet together. The plan would work if Lord Capulet hadn't moved the wadding to Wednesday because by that time Romeo would have gotten the message. If could change the plan I would have just told them to just run away and never come back. If I were in Juliet's position I would have gone along with the plan if there was nothing else. In conclusion, the Friar should not be blamed for what eventually happens because if its anyones fault,its Lord Capulets.
1.14
The friars plan for getting romeo and juliet together isn't good. The friars plan is bound to have something wrong. The plan could of worked if it was planned better. An alternative to the plan is juliet just running away. I wouldn't of went with the plan. The friar could be blamed for the killings. In conclusion the plan wasn't that good
1.8
I think that the Friar was right to get Romeo and Juliet together because they loved each other. The benefits of Romeo and Juliet being together would be that it could bring the families to get along. I think it could of worked if Romeo and Juliet would of talk to their parents and confessed to them what they did. I think that instead of Juliet drinking the potion she should of ran away with Romeo and then came back with him like a day after the wedding day. I wouldn't go with the plan because i wouldn't drink any kind of potion. I would just run away with Romeo. I think it was the Friars fault in the way that he married them, but then again it wasn't his fault because Romeo and Juliet are the ones who decided to get married.
1.
-The Friar's plan for getting Romeo and Juliet together wasn't a good idea from the start. For one thing Juliet didn't know if the potion would work or if the after affects would effect her in a bad way. Another way Romeo and Juliet would of been able to be together. Would be to sneak out at night and run away. All in all the Friar should be blamed for what happened because it was his herb.
period1 computer26
i actually agree with [5] because they could of just ran away together instead.
1.12
Yes I think it is a good idea but in not sure if its going to work. It could be a poison or it won't work. Romeo and Juliet can be together in happiness. Im not sure it would ever work because I don't think they could make a potion. Have her run away and Romeo meet her somewhere. Yes I would go along with it because it would be fun. I don't know what happens so I can't tell you. In conclusion, I like what the friar is trying to do.
period 1 computer 5
I agree with 14
I think they should just run away. It makes a lot more sense.
per.1 13
The Friars plan to get Romeo and Juliet together is a very good idea. The drawbacks are the chances of Romeo does not come, Juliet dies, or the potion does not work. The benefits are Romeo and Juliet are set free to love each other. An alternative plan could have been Juliet could have just ran away. I would not go through with the plan. All and all, the Friar is not to blame because they killed them selfs.
period 1. Computer 20.
In my opinion the Friar's plan is not a very good idea because there is very many good and bad consequence to it. The potential benefits/rewards of it is that Romeo and Juliet might end up being able to be together, but Juliet could also die,the potion could be poison, and Romeo might not save Juliet in time. It could have worked if the Friar got the information to Romeo on time to tell him before he killed hims self. They could have told Romeo before Juliet took the potion and Romeo would have known before he killed himself. If I was Juliet i would not have gone along with the plan because of the consequences that could happen. In conclusion, the Friar should be blamed for what eventually happens to Romeo and Juliet.
Period 1. #19.
I think that the Friar's plan for getting Romeo and Juliet together is a good idea for their time period. The potential drawbacks/hazards of the plan are if Romeo doesn't get the message then something bad can happen,they will have to leave their families, and the potion might not work. The potential benefits/rewards of the plan are they will be together, and their families might stop fighting.I think that the plan could have worked if Romeo gets the message in time. Some alternatives to the plan could be the Friar could go and tell Romeo face to face instead of a letter. If I was in Romeo's or Juliet's situation I think I would have gone along with the plan because it seems like a pretty good idea. All in all, I think that the Friar should be blamed but not just him because all he did was secretly marry them and was trying to help them so it is partly his fault.
p1.25
to #5
I wouldn't really doubt the friar's capability to conjure potions. I would assume he ran a apothecary at some point as a apprentice.
#24
The friars plan may not seem like a good idea, but its the only one that he can think of. The potential drawback is that what if romeo may never get the message. The benefits are that if the plan works then they will be together. I'm not sure what a different plan would have been. If I was in Romeos posistion i think i would do anything to be with her. The friar should not be blamed for what happens. It is not his fault.
1.12
I agree with 14 they could run away.
#23/per1
The plan the Friar had was overly complicated. There for it was a terrible plan. A better plan would have been just have Juliet run away with Romeo. that would have worked perfectly, they couldn't have been tracked. The friar probably knew it would end in death. How the hell does his plan end well she ether suffocates or goes insane or lives it all ends in DEATH! Yay death. So clearly the Friar is an idiot and his plan was terrible. If it where me i would tell him think of something else.
1.09
I think that the Friar's plan is not very good. The hazards are that Juliet can suffocate, or the friar can give her poision instead of a potion. I can't think of any benefits. I don't think the plan could have ever worked, but im not sure why I just dont. I probably wouldn't of gone along with it, because there is some hazards. an alternative would be to run away. The friar should be part of the blame for being the person to come up with the plan, but also Romeo and Juliet's fault for going along with it.
1.
- I agree with #8 it would of probably been better if they talked to there parents about there love for each other.
p1.25
to #5 about running away.
I agree with both of you guys. Yay running away!
1.09
I agree with 14 they should of ran away instead
1.15
The friar's plan to get Romeo and Juliet together was a good idea and for good reasons. The potential drawbacks/hazards of the plan are that the family's could find out early and kill the friar and Romeo and Juliet could be separated forever which would lead them to commit suicide. The potential benefits/rewards of the plan could be that they family's could see the love because of these two loves which could make them stop the fighting. The plan could have worked because Romeo and Juliet are very secretive about meeting each other. Some alternatives to the plan could have been to go to a different city and get married and live long lives together. I would have gone along with the plan in Romeo and Juliet because it would be in the name of love peace and happiness. In conclusion, the friar shouldn't be blamed for what eventually happens because the messenger fault for being to slow and Juliet's fault for telling her father that she is willing to marry Paris.
period 1. computer 20
I completely agree with number 25 but i want to know how it would be lord Capulet's fault?
He made his point clear when he said if any "drama" was created in Verona that they would be banished and he let Romeo go easy when he only banished him instead of killing him.
#23
to any one who reads this.
Where did he learn that kind of potion only medicine men who studied santaria knew that so something seems off to me....
Period 1. #19.
I agree with (5) because they could have just ran away with each other.
Period 1. #19.
I agree with(8) because the Friar was just trying to help them.
1.11:
The friar's plan for getting Romeo and Juliet together is not a good plan. THe potential hazards of this plan is if the potion doesn't work and Juliet actually dies, or if it doesn't work and she has to marry Paris. In which case she threatened to kill herself. The potential rewards of the potion plan is to get Romeo and Juliet together. I do not think the plan could have ever worked because Romeo is rash. Even if the friar himself warned Romeo he would probably act the same. One alternative to the plan could have been to get Juliet banished, too, or even help her run away. I don't think I would go along with the plan because I would be scared that the potion would really kill me. All in all the friar should be blamed for what eventually happens because it was his plan, and he married them in the first place.
1.10
The Friar's plan for Juliet is to give her the potion and make her look dead. So the parents think she is dead. It is not a good idea because Juliet will never get to see her parents again. The drawbacks of the plan would be for the potion to not work and her to kill herself. The benefit of the plan would be that she can marry who she wants because the parents think she is dead. It could have worked but i would never want to do that because i want to see my parents. I would not go along with the plan because i love my parents and i would not want to be separated from them. Yes the Friar should be blamed for what happens.
Post a Comment