I think it was a bad idea not to tell the crew because then they would have not eaten the sheep. He probily did this because he was tried of his men doing things that might get them in trouble. This turn out worse. I would have told my crew about all that Circe warned him about. I wouldn't be mad if the crew listen to everything I said. Shielding people from the truth is not good because they'll find out sooner or later, it would be better if they know now instead of getting mad later.
I didn't think it was a good idea to tell his crew about the dangers Circe described for him. Odysseus had to do this because for his men not fear anything. Odysseus made things turn out worser. I probably would have done the same as Odysseus if I was in his place. If I was a member of Odysseus crew I wouldn't be angry at him if he didn't reveal the truth it isn't his fault. I think shielding the truth from people is sort of a good idea. I f you ever tell the truth people may like you less
He should have told them about the dangers.He want to make it home and circe told him to go to the land of the dead.wirse cause he lost his whole crew and his boat.Idk maybe.Ya I would of wanted him to tell me everythang.Depends what your shielding,but proble.
People should never be sheielded from the truth. But we should at some measures, because the lies keep us stable. Some people want to know the truth, but most of us can not handle it. If the truth got let out people would go insane. But who says insane is a bad thing.
No he should have told them all of the dangers. This is because they could have prepared for it and survived. He did is i think because he could'nt tell them. Things turned out bad for them Odyssey lost 6 of his crew. I would have told my krew what we were going to be faceing. Yes i wuld be angry because everyone deserves to no the truth sometimes. Shielding people from the turth isn't a good idea at all over all.
I don't think that it wasnt a good idea for odysseus to not tell his crew about what circe said. He did that because then they wouldve started freaking out. It turns out bad for his crew but not for odysseus. I dont know if i wouldve done the same thing or not. Yes i would because that means i would be dead. It sometimes is a good thing if you shield the truth from others.
It was good idea for Odysseus to only tell his crew about the part of dangers Circe described to him. The Odysseus did this because he didn't want his men to worry and be scared them. It made thing worse I would say because he lost all his men and he still haven't got home. If I were in the Odysseus shoe I would have din the same thing so I wouldn't worried my men and they would've never back down. I would be angry at the Odysseus but then I would understand him as well. Clearly, you should always tell your friends the truth in a situation.
I think odyddeyous should be honest wit his crew!its good too be honest. not sure.hech yes,i hate it when ppl lie to me.unless its a good reason or tryn to protect me.nope...
I think that it was a good idea for odysseus to tell his men about the dangers tht were about to face thim. If he would had told thim thay would have ran away like little b!!!hs. It made his situation beter because he did not have to deal with those cry babys. In conclusion not teeling his crew was the best thing that could of hapend to him.
I believe that odysseus not telling his men was a good idea because his men would probably not followed him to that trail. odysseus did not tell them because he was scared that his men would be to scare. i think that if i was put in that place i would not have done that same i would have told my men and tell them that we would make it through together.i would not be angry if i was a member of his crew and he did not say anything i would understand. Some times it is a good thing to hide the truth depending on reason
2/3 #3 I have to agree with computer #23 about them knowing anything that they might have trouble with. It is a good idea to let them know in order to prepare and to check if they need something.
I think it was a good idea not to tell his crew about the rest because he did not want to wory them. He probibly did not want to frighten them. Yes I would do the same thing. No I would not be mad. If you want to sheild peole from the truth from someone make sure it is not pesonal.
I dont think that it was a good idea because he needs to be loyal to his crew and he needs to let them know what is going to be in the journey ahead. why he did this is because he doesn't want his crew to worry about the journey. It turned out worse because he didn't tell them everything. I would tell my crew everything that she said and what dangers are ahead in the journey. I would be very mad at odysseus if he didn't telll me the whole truth. It is only a good idea when you are doing it to protect someone but this was very important to tell them the truth.
16 comments:
3-17 #05
I think that it was a good idea for odysseus to only tell his crew about part of the dangers because they would have mabe not moved on with odysseus.
2/3 #3
I think it was a bad idea not to tell the crew because then they would have not eaten the sheep. He probily did this because he was tried of his men doing things that might get them in trouble. This turn out worse. I would have told my crew about all that Circe warned him about. I wouldn't be mad if the crew listen to everything I said. Shielding people from the truth is not good because they'll find out sooner or later, it would be better if they know now instead of getting mad later.
2/3 #1
I didn't think it was a good idea to tell his crew about the dangers Circe described for him. Odysseus had to do this because for his men not fear anything. Odysseus made things turn out worser. I probably would have done the same as Odysseus if I was in his place. If I was a member of Odysseus crew I wouldn't be angry at him if he didn't reveal the truth it isn't his fault. I think shielding the truth from people is sort of a good idea. I f you ever tell the truth people may like you less
He should have told them about the dangers.He want to make it home and circe told him to go to the land of the dead.wirse cause he lost his whole crew and his boat.Idk maybe.Ya I would of wanted him to tell me everythang.Depends what your shielding,but proble.
2-3
19
People should never be sheielded from the truth. But we should at some measures, because the lies keep us stable. Some people want to know the truth, but most of us can not handle it. If the truth got let out people would go insane. But who says insane is a bad thing.
2/3
comp #23
No he should have told them all of the dangers. This is because they could have prepared for it and survived. He did is i think because he could'nt tell them. Things turned out bad for them Odyssey lost 6 of his crew. I would have told my krew what we were going to be faceing. Yes i wuld be angry because everyone deserves to no the truth sometimes.
Shielding people from the turth isn't a good idea at all over all.
2/3.7
I don't think that it wasnt a good idea for odysseus to not tell his crew about what circe said. He did that because then they wouldve started freaking out. It turns out bad for his crew but not for odysseus. I dont know if i wouldve done the same thing or not. Yes i would because that means i would be dead. It sometimes is a good thing if you shield the truth from others.
period:two, computer;sixteen.
It was good idea for Odysseus to only tell his crew about the part of dangers Circe described to him. The Odysseus did this because he didn't want his men to worry and be scared them. It made thing worse I would say because he lost all his men and he still haven't got home. If I were in the Odysseus shoe I would have din the same thing so I wouldn't worried my men and they would've never back down. I would be angry at the Odysseus but then I would understand him as well. Clearly, you should always tell your friends the truth in a situation.
2/3.#18
I think odyddeyous should be honest wit his crew!its good too be honest.
not sure.hech yes,i hate it when ppl lie to me.unless its a good reason or tryn to protect me.nope...
2/3
comp #23
I agree with 19 on the first couple parts. Like about not bein shielded from the truth. Also, That lies do keep most people stable.
2 16
I agree with computer 7 because he did do a good idea to not tell his men about the whole thing or they would've freaking out.
2/3 #2
I think that it was a good idea for odysseus to tell his men about the dangers tht were about to face thim. If he would had told thim thay would have ran away like little b!!!hs. It made his situation beter because he did not have to deal with those cry babys. In conclusion not teeling his crew was the best thing that could of hapend to him.
I believe that odysseus not telling his men was a good idea because his men would probably not followed him to that trail. odysseus did not tell them because he was scared that his men would be to scare. i think that if i was put in that place i would not have done that same i would have told my men and tell them that we would make it through together.i would not be angry if i was a member of his crew and he did not say anything i would understand. Some times it is a good thing to hide the truth depending on reason
2/3 #3
I have to agree with computer #23 about them knowing anything that they might have trouble with. It is a good idea to let them know in order to prepare and to check if they need something.
P:2/3 COM#:10
I think it was a good idea not to tell his crew about the rest because he did not want to wory them. He probibly did not want to frighten them. Yes I would do the same thing. No I would not be mad. If you want to sheild peole from the truth from someone make sure it is not pesonal.
2/321
I dont think that it was a good idea because he needs to be loyal to his crew and he needs to let them know what is going to be in the journey ahead. why he did this is because he doesn't want his crew to worry about the journey. It turned out worse because he didn't tell them everything. I would tell my crew everything that she said and what dangers are ahead in the journey. I would be very mad at odysseus if he didn't telll me the whole truth. It is only a good idea when you are doing it to protect someone but this was very important to tell them the truth.
Post a Comment