No! People should never be shielded from the truth. I am always brutally honest when I tell people things, if I hate you, I'll tell you. Its nothing that should be hidden. Even though it may have helped Odysseus and his men, but you still should tell the truth to the best of your ability.
I think it was a good idea to only tell his crew part of what they were going to face. Odysseus did this to prevent his crew from panicking. I would have done the same thing, even though it would have made me mad if I were one of the crew members. Shielding the truth from people can sometimes be better in the long run.
In my opinion,it was not a good idea for Odysseus to not tell him men about ALL the dangers about Circe. I think he didn't tell them because then they wouldn't go with him. It turned out way worse than it should have. If I were in his place, I definatly would not have gone there. I would have told my crew what dangers lie ahead and sea if they want to continue. I would be angry if I was a part of his crew and he didn't tell me but I would be dead before I could be angry. In conclusion,shielding people from the truth is never a good idea. It will lead to danger or death.
1.12 It was a bad idea for him not to tell his men about the circe. He did it to make it so his men weren't worried. It mad it worse because they all died. No I would of told my men to watch out. If I was part of the crew I would be pissed that me didn't tell me the truth.In conclusion, I think it was wrong for him not to tell his men the truth.
1.14 I think that Odysseus should have told his men about all of the dangers. Odysseus did this because he didn't want to scare his men. thing didn't turn out that good for his men. I would have been really been pissed at odysseus if he didn't tell me about dangers. Sheilding the truth is not good all of the time.
1.16 People shouldn't be kept from the truth because what if something bad was going to happen to that person, and letting them know the truth then it would prevent them from that happening to them. it was kind of a good thing that he didn't tell his crew about the dangers ahead of them because they would have been scared to do the things odysseus wanted them to do. this is why i think that he shouldn't didn't tell them.
I don't think it was a bad idea to tell his crew about the dangers circe brought him. he did this because they would be aware. It made things better so they would know what was going to happen. i would have done the same thing. as you can see i think it was a good idea.
period 1. Computer 20 In my opinion it was not a godd idea for Odysseus to only tell his crew about part of the dangers Circe described for him. It was not a godd idea because all his men dies. He only told them part of the dangers to prevent his crew from panicing. I think it made things worse because they all still died. If i was in Odysseus place then I would have told my crew all of the dangers that they may face. Yes, I would be angry that odysseus didn't reveal the full truth to his crew. Shielding people from the truth in my opinion isn't a very good idea to me.
it wasn't a good idea for odysseus to not tell his crew about only part of the dangers. odysseus only told his crew about part of it so they would continue the voyage. it made things turn out worse because he lost all his crew. no i would have told the crew everything so they knew what was going to happen. yes i would be mad if he didn't tell me. all in all shielding people from the truth is mostly always a bad idea.
Period 1.#19. I think that it was a bad idea for Odysseus to only tell his crew about part of the dangers Circe described for him. I think that Odysseus did this so his crew wouldn't panic. I think that I would have done the same thing in Odysseus's place. I think that if I were a member of Odysseus's crew,I wouldn't be angry that Odysseus didn't reveal the full truth. All in all I think that shielding people from the truth can be a good idea but it depends on the situation.
It was a good idea for Odysseus to tell his crew about the dangers that Circe described. Odysseus told them so that they may be prepared for the dangers to come. It made it worse because they all died except for Odysseus. Yes i would have done the same thing because then they would know the dangers that were about to come. I would be angry yes that he didn't tell me the full truth, but would still admire him for what he did tell me. In conclusion, shielding people from the truth is a bad idea.
1.11: I think it was a good idea for Odysseus to only tell his crew members about some of the dangers. I think it was good idea to do this because if he would've told the crew everything they would have freaked out and not wanted to go. In a way it made things better because when the worse events happened no one knew what was going on except for Odysseus. If I was part of Odysseus's crew I would be mad that he didn't tell us, but i would understand. All in all, sometimes shielding people from the truth can be good.
23.not sure on the date.1 Odysseus was not wrong to not tell his men the whole truth. they probably couldn't handle the truth. lying makes the world go round. people are stupid and need to be lied to. thats my opinion on Odysseus lying to his men
09.1 I think that Odysseus should'nt have only told them part of the dangers. I dont know why he did it maybe to not scare them.It made things turn out I think worse. I would'nt have done the same thing because they need to know whst else to watch out for, because they are in more danger when they arent watching out. Yes I would be angry, because I would be in more danger because I wouldnt know what to watch out for. Shielding people from the truth isnt a good idea, because like I said before they will be in more danger.
#18-1st period Odysseus makes some good and some bad decisions, this is one of the bad ones. I mean i guess it was smart to not tell them all of it one the account if he didn't want to freak them out but it was still dumb of him not to tell them all the warnings because it would have prepared them and its always good to be honest.In the end if i was Odysseus i would have told the crew it would have been the right thing.
1.26 I don't think it was a good idea for odysseus because they could have been prepared for whatever dangers are up ahead.He is afraid of how afraid they will be afraid and then flee him and he will not have a crew anymore. i think it turned out for the worse because his men ate the cattle and it turned into their deaths. I would have but i would have told my men about not to eat the cattle. I would be angry that he didn't tell me about the dangers. In conclusion, i think it depends on what you shield people from.
1. #6 I do think that sometimes people should be shielded from the truth. It was a good idea for Odysseus to only tell his crew part of the dangers that Circe described for him. Odysseus probably did this because he didn't want his crew members to get scared and not want to carry on with their journey back home. This made things turn out better in the beginning, but when they got past Scylla, Odysseus should of told them not to eat the cattle. I probably would of done the same thing in Odysseus's place, but I would of told them about the cattle. If I was a member of the crew however I would of been very angry at Odysseus for not revealing the truth.
#24 I believe that it is a great idea for people to not know the truth. I say this because lies keep the public from having chaos. It was a good idea because then his men would not want to continue on their quest. It was better that way.
1. -I think it was a good idea for Odyesseus to tell his crew about the dangers Circe told him. He did this because he wants them to be awere of the situation. I really don't know much because I was not here
20 comments:
P1.#25
No! People should never be shielded from the truth. I am always brutally honest when I tell people things, if I hate you, I'll tell you. Its nothing that should be hidden. Even though it may have helped Odysseus and his men, but you still should tell the truth to the best of your ability.
per. 1 #17
I think it was a good idea to only tell his crew part of what they were going to face. Odysseus did this to prevent his crew from panicking. I would have done the same thing, even though it would have made me mad if I were one of the crew members. Shielding the truth from people can sometimes be better in the long run.
period 1 computer 5
In my opinion,it was not a good idea for Odysseus to not tell him men about ALL the dangers about Circe. I think he didn't tell them because then they wouldn't go with him. It turned out way worse than it should have. If I were in his place, I definatly would not have gone there. I would have told my crew what dangers lie ahead and sea if they want to continue. I would be angry if I was a part of his crew and he didn't tell me but I would be dead before I could be angry. In conclusion,shielding people from the truth is never a good idea. It will lead to danger or death.
1.12
It was a bad idea for him not to tell his men about the circe. He did it to make it so his men weren't worried. It mad it worse because they all died. No I would of told my men to watch out. If I was part of the crew I would be pissed that me didn't tell me the truth.In conclusion, I think it was wrong for him not to tell his men the truth.
1.14
I think that Odysseus should have told his men about all of the dangers. Odysseus did this because he didn't want to scare his men. thing didn't turn out that good for his men. I would have been really been pissed at odysseus if he didn't tell me about dangers. Sheilding the truth is not good all of the time.
1.16
People shouldn't be kept from the truth because what if something bad was going to happen to that person, and letting them know the truth then it would prevent them from that happening to them. it was kind of a good thing that he didn't tell his crew about the dangers ahead of them because they would have been scared to do the things odysseus wanted them to do. this is why i think that he shouldn't didn't tell them.
period 1
computer 4
I don't think it was a bad idea to tell his crew about the dangers circe brought him. he did this because they would be aware. It made things better so they would know what was going to happen. i would have done the same thing. as you can see i think it was a good idea.
period 1. Computer 20
In my opinion it was not a godd idea for Odysseus to only tell his crew about part of the dangers Circe described for him. It was not a godd idea because all his men dies. He only told them part of the dangers to prevent his crew from panicing. I think it made things worse because they all still died. If i was in Odysseus place then I would have told my crew all of the dangers that they may face. Yes, I would be angry that odysseus didn't reveal the full truth to his crew. Shielding people from the truth in my opinion isn't a very good idea to me.
01.07
it wasn't a good idea for odysseus to not tell his crew about only part of the dangers. odysseus only told his crew about part of it so they would continue the voyage. it made things turn out worse because he lost all his crew. no i would have told the crew everything so they knew what was going to happen. yes i would be mad if he didn't tell me. all in all shielding people from the truth is mostly always a bad idea.
Period 1.#19.
I think that it was a bad idea for Odysseus to only tell his crew about part of the dangers Circe described for him. I think that Odysseus did this so his crew wouldn't panic. I think that I would have done the same thing in Odysseus's place. I think that if I were a member of Odysseus's crew,I wouldn't be angry that Odysseus didn't reveal the full truth. All in all I think that shielding people from the truth can be a good idea but it depends on the situation.
1.15
It was a good idea for Odysseus to tell his crew about the dangers that Circe described. Odysseus told them so that they may be prepared for the dangers to come. It made it worse because they all died except for Odysseus. Yes i would have done the same thing because then they would know the dangers that were about to come. I would be angry yes that he didn't tell me the full truth, but would still admire him for what he did tell me. In conclusion, shielding people from the truth is a bad idea.
period 1 computer 5
I disagree with 17 because everyone has a right to know the WHOLE truth. Wouldn't you want people to tell you the truth?
1.11:
I think it was a good idea for Odysseus to only tell his crew members about some of the dangers. I think it was good idea to do this because if he would've told the crew everything they would have freaked out and not wanted to go. In a way it made things better because when the worse events happened no one knew what was going on except for Odysseus. If I was part of Odysseus's crew I would be mad that he didn't tell us, but i would understand. All in all, sometimes shielding people from the truth can be good.
23.not sure on the date.1
Odysseus was not wrong to not tell his men the whole truth. they probably couldn't handle the truth. lying makes the world go round. people are stupid and need to be lied to. thats my opinion on Odysseus lying to his men
09.1
I think that Odysseus should'nt have only told them part of the dangers.
I dont know why he did it maybe to not scare them.It made things turn out I think worse. I would'nt have done the same thing because they need to know whst else to watch out for, because they are in more danger when they arent watching out. Yes I would be angry, because I would be in more danger because I wouldnt know what to watch out for. Shielding people from the truth isnt a good idea, because like I said before they will be in more danger.
#18-1st period
Odysseus makes some good and some bad decisions, this is one of the bad ones. I mean i guess it was smart to not tell them all of it one the account if he didn't want to freak them out but it was still dumb of him not to tell them all the warnings because it would have prepared them and its always good to be honest.In the end if i was Odysseus i would have told the crew it would have been the right thing.
1.26 I don't think it was a good idea for odysseus because they could have been prepared for whatever dangers are up ahead.He is afraid of how afraid they will be afraid and then flee him and he will not have a crew anymore. i think it turned out for the worse because his men ate the cattle and it turned into their deaths. I would have but i would have told my men about not to eat the cattle. I would be angry that he didn't tell me about the dangers. In conclusion, i think it depends on what you shield people from.
1. #6 I do think that sometimes people should be shielded from the truth. It was a good idea for Odysseus to only tell his crew part of the dangers that Circe described for him. Odysseus probably did this because he didn't want his crew members to get scared and not want to carry on with their journey back home. This made things turn out better in the beginning, but when they got past Scylla, Odysseus should of told them not to eat the cattle. I probably would of done the same thing in Odysseus's place, but I would of told them about the cattle. If I was a member of the crew however I would of been very angry at Odysseus for not revealing the truth.
#24
I believe that it is a great idea for people to not know the truth. I say this because lies keep the public from having chaos. It was a good idea because then his men would not want to continue on their quest. It was better that way.
1.
-I think it was a good idea for Odyesseus to tell his crew about the dangers Circe told him. He did this because he wants them to be awere of the situation. I really don't know much because I was not here
Post a Comment