Thursday, March 4, 2010

Period 1

See the post above and respond here.

23 comments:

Anonymous said...

1.14
Odysseus is to blame for what happens to his men. Odysseus and his men are to blame for raiding the cyclops home. The cyclops is somewhat to blame for being an ingracious host because Odysseus went to his home uninvited. I think that odysseus would be the one to get charged if this case went to trial. I sympathize with the cyclopse because it is his home where he was attacked. In conclusion the whole thing could of been prevented if odysseus didn't lead his men in the cave.

Anonymous said...

1.12
I think that odysseus is to blame for what happened to them. It is all of there faults because they all chose to go and raid the home. No the cyclops just acted nice to odysseus to be nice. I think that odysseus would be to blame because he wasn't in harm or trouble. He just hurt the cyclops to get away. In conclusion, they should of just stayed away from the cyclops.

Anonymous said...

1.14
I agree with 12 because it is all Odysseus's fault.

Anonymous said...

computer 22
period 1

I think that Odysseus is to blame because after he blinded the Cyclops him and his men got onto their boat and as they were leaving Odysseus just kept on bragging on who invaded the Cyclops home and ate all of his food and thats why the Cyclops attacked his guest because when odysseus was being stupid and telling the Cyclops who blinded him and invaded his home so it pissed the Cyclops off and tried to kill them

Anonymous said...

24
If anything i would have to say that it was Polyphimuses fault for everything that happened. Because if it wasn't for him then no one would have died. He went to the Cyclops home and disturbed him. It wasn't the Cyclops fault.

Anonymous said...

Period 1. # 19.
Odysseus is to blame for what happened to him and his men. I think that Odysseus and his men are more at fault for raiding the Cyclops's home and eating his food. I don't think that the Cyclops is to blame for being an ingracious host who attacks his guests. I think that if the case was brought to trial Odysseus would be convicted. I sympathize the Cyclops the most because he lost sight. All in all, I think that the problem could have been prevented if Odysseus and his men didn't bother the Cyclops.

Anonymous said...

period 1 computer 5

In my opinion, Odysseus is to blame for what happened to him and his men. He is also at fault for raiding the Cyclopses home and eating all of his food. Its not the Cyclopses fault for protecting his 'guests', they broke in and ate all his food,if I were the cyclops I would have been so mad and eaten them to. If the case was brought to trial I think they would both be in trouble because Odysseus broke in and stole food and the Cyclops killed people.I don't sympathize anyone. I think there both in the wrong. In conclusion, it could have been prevented by Odysseus not braking into the Cyclopses home.

Anonymous said...

1.8
I would say that Odysseus and his men are to blame because of what they do to the Cyclops house. At the same time i think that Cyclops is at fault because he should know how to act around people and not just kill them like that. I think the person who would be convicted would have to be Cyclops. I think that he would be the one convicted because he's the one who killed Odysseus and his men.

Anonymous said...

1 27
The Cyclops is to blame for the fait of Odsseus's men. Odysseus and him men are not at fault. The Cyclops is to blame for bing a ingracious host. If it was brought to tril i thingk Odysseus would win. i sympithiz for Odysseus. it could have been pervented if Cyclops had been a better host.

Anonymous said...

1-11:
Odysseus is the one to blame for the incident for what happens to Odysseus and his men. Odysseus and his men are at fault because they went into the Cyclops's home. It was uncalled for, for the Cyclops to eat the men, but the men shouldn't have been in there in the first place. If this case was brought to trial they both would be at fault. Odysseus would get in trouble for trespassing and the Cyclops would get convicted for murder. I don't sympathize with Odysseus nor the Cyclops. They both could have prevented conflict. All in all the entire conflict could have been prevented if Odysseus would have stayed out of the cave and left the Cyclops alone, if he wouldn't have bragged about stabbing him in the eye. The Cyclops could also have prevented the problem. He could have left the men alone and not eaten them.

Anonymous said...

p.1 comp. 16
I think that its odysseus' fault that the Cyclopes incident happened. it is kinda Cyclopes fault that he is so mean to his quest and its kinda the parents fault too because, they raised him to be how he is. I think the person who would be convicted if it came to trial would be the cyclopes because, Odysseus was just trying to save his friends and his life, also because the Cyclopes was trying to kill them and not let them get home. I sympathize with odysseus because he is just trying to get home to his son and his wife, i don't think he wanted any trouble. it could have been prevented by the Cyclopes just letting them go home and odysseus not getting him drunk and stabbing him in the eye.

computer #2 said...

Odysseus is to blame for the deaths of his men and the cyclopes incident. yes odysseus and his men are at fault for raiding the cyclopses cave. they are at fault because thats not their property. yes the cyclopes is to blame for not being a good host because he's not a friendly person.

Anonymous said...

1.15

Odysseus is to blame for what happens to Odysseus and his men. Odysseus and his men are more at fault for raiding the Cyclops's home and eating his men because they didn't even care who's food it was. The Cyclops is to blame for being an ingracious who attacks and eats his guests, but Odysseus did go into the Cyclops home and eat his food. Odysseus would the the one found convicted if this case was brought to trial because Odysseus did raid the Cyclops home. I sympathize for Odysseus because he wants to brag so much and after a while he loses control of what he is doing. This could have been prevented by Odysseus could of used his whit to check the Cyclops's home first then continue with a plan. In conclusion, Odysseus is the one to blame for what happens to him and his men.

Anonymous said...

1-11:
I agree with #22 because Odysseus could have prevented the entire thing.

Anonymous said...

1.26 Odysseus men are to blame for their own deaths because they eat the sweet lotus. Yes odysseus and his men are at fault for raiding the cyclops home because they should have just kept sailing on. No because they are eating his food and trying to steal his sheep. Odysseus would be convicted because they were trying to steal the Cyclops food from his property. I am more sympathetic to the cyclops because he was just protecting his property.IN conclusion, if Odysseus had just kept sailing on and not stopping on the island thy might have not got to all the trouble.

Anonymous said...

1.10
Odysseus and his men are to blame when they get eaten by the cyclops. Him and his men should not be snooping around the Cyclopses home and eating all of his food. No the Cyclops did not envite them to his house. Most likely the Cyclops would get convicted. I sympathize the Cyclops because he had a reason to do what he did. Odysseus and his men could have not gone to the Cyclops house.

Anonymous said...

Period 1
computer 4

I think Odysseus is to blame for what happens to his people. I think Odysseus and his men are responsible for raiding the Cyclops home and eating his food. I think if there was a trial that Odysseus and the Cyclops would go to jail because Odysseus stabbed the Cyclops in the eye and the Cyclops ate the people. The problem could have been avoided if Odysseus would not have went into the Cyclops home.

Anonymous said...

1.07

odysseus is to blame for what happened to him and his men. no they had to do it for survival. the CYclops is to blame because instead of helping odysseus and his men the Cyclops tied eating them instead. odysseus and his men would most likely be convicted in a trial for robbing the Cyclops. i sympathize more with odysseus because he did what had to to survive. in conclusion to prevent this situation the Cyclops should help.

Anonymous said...

09.1
I kind of think that they are both to blame. I think this because if the Cyclops wouldnt have been so rude then it probably wouldnt of happened, but if Odysseus wouldnt of went into his home then it wouildnt of happened. So I think they are both to blame. If this case was brought to trial they wouild probably blame Odysseus because he is the one who stabbed Cyclops in the eye. The situatoin could of been prevented by Odysseus not going into the Cyclops home.

Anonymous said...

per 1 laptop 13
I think that it is the whole crew and Odysseuses fault because if they had not pissed off Zeus they would not be their. That was a pretty stupid idea to raid a Syclopses home. The Syclopes has all the right to eat the men who invaded his home.Odysseus would loose. all in all if Zeus was not pissed they would have been safer.

Anonymous said...

1.
- Odysseus is to blame for what happened to his men. Odysseus and his men are in fault for raiding the cyclopes home and it was probably why he was such a bad host. I think Odysseus and the Cyclopes would be convicted. Odysseus shouldn't of barged in on Cyclopes land and the Cyclopes shouldn't of killed Odysseus men.

Anonymous said...

6/7.3 Odysseus is to blame for what had happened to he his men. Because cyclopes had the right to do what he did, he broke into an eating his food. No he should not be blamed for what he did because it was not his fault.

Anonymous said...

period 1
22

i don't think people should be shielded from the truth because when you tell people lies it will all just backfire on you in time and it will make you seem like a lier and you will be putting yourself in a hole thats hard to get yourself out of.